Trenton 250: Washington feels the need to enter New Jersey

November 5, 2026
History
Watching the Battle of Fort Washington, 1776 Painted 1929, by John Ward Dunsmore (1856-1945)

Believing that the British would very soon begin crossing into New Jersey seeking food for their huge army, on November 10Washington began marching the portion of his forces selected to cross to New Jersey from North Castle in Westchester County and crossed over with them to the west side of the Hudson at Peekskill. At this point, Trenton apprentice cooper and five-month militiaman Private John Jemes and other men wounded at White Plains, “were sent in baggage wagons to Bethlehem in Pennsylvania where he remained in the hospital there until the month of March 1777 when [he] was discharged cured.” Washington was continually losing troops to illness in addition to combat wounds.

By November 12, the leading elements of the American army under General Lord Stirling were at Hackensack six miles west ofFort Lee. Washington arrived at Fort Lee on November 13 and then moved on to Hackensack where he set up his headquarters. While he had divided his troops in a way that seemed risky to military strategists, Washington was counting on General Lee to make expeditious moves with a large number of troops to support him if the British did come into New Jersey and thus remove the threat of attack on New England.

Further north, at Lake George, Captain Joseph Brearley of the 2nd New Jersey Continental Regiment, along with other men from the Trenton area, got orders to begin their journey home since their enlistments ended in a week. However, when they arrived atAlbany they were ordered instead to go immediately to join Washington’s army because they were greatly needed. Those who agreedto extend their enlistments would sail down the Hudson River to Esopus [Kingston] and then march to Morristown, New Jersey where they would arrive about December 3. Those not extending their enlistment and leaving the army would simply continue walking to their homes. Their friends and relatives in the Trenton area must have wondered about them, especially as events were developing in November.

By Thomas Davies, now owned by the New York Library

At 4:00pm on November 15, General Nathanael Greene at Fort Lee issued orders to General Nathaniel Heard “to hasten on” and bring his five-month levy brigade to the Fort ready to support Fort Washington, directly across the Hudson River, valiantlyresisting attack by the British. As they looked across the river on the 16th, Fort Washington was weakening under the Britishonslaught and in danger of falling to the enemy. These five-month levies had earlier departed their posts at Fort Washington when their companies moved out to White Plains where they had engaged in battle with the British in late October. After that battle, WilliamHoughton and about ten others from his company were ordered back to Fort Washington briefly “on command,” that is, temporary duty, to reinforce the garrison and continue work on the defenses. Fortunately, they had rejoined their company after Heard’s Brigade marched with the main army and crossed the Hudson to New Jersey. They had crossed at King’s Ferry and caught up with them ontheir march south towards Fort Lee.

When Fort Washington surrendered to the British, several men with ties to Trenton, including John Beatty, Thomas Janney,Hamilton Martin, and Timothy Ryan of the Fifth Pennsylvania Regiment were among the captured soldiers. All those captured were treated terribly, and many would perish, including a number imprisoned on the infamous no longer seaworthy ship hulks the British used for prisons. Later they learned that only 800 of the captured men survived after suffering through a long, cruel imprisonment.

Lieutenant Colonel Lambert Cadwalader was captured at Fort Washington but soon released without parole and sent home in return for a kindness his father had shown to British General Prescott when he was a prisoner in Philadelphia. Today’s Cadwalader Park bears the name of his family which was associated with the farm and house, then known as Greenwood (and today as Ellerslie), for several generations in the 18th century. Cadwalader considered himself honor bound to secure the release of a British officer of equal rank before he would takeup arms again. A collection of circumstances prevented this and he remained inactive until January 1779, when he resigned hiscommission (a full colonel since 1777) so as not to stand in the way of promotion for other officers.

Washington wrote to Congress from General Greene’s quarters describing the attack on and surrender of Fort Washington. He didn’t yet know the number of killed and wounded on either side, “but from the heaviness and continuance of fire in some places, I imagine there must have been considerable execution.” Washington decided to hold General Beall’s and General Heard’s brigades atFort Lee to reinforce that post and protect the military stores located there.

Captain Joab Houghton’s company got to Fort Lee on the 16th “only in time to see the surrender of Fort Washington”, an outcome that truly upset Houghton and the members of his company because before, between, and after the battles of Brooklyn,Harlem Heights, and White Plains they had “all worked so hard on [digging] the trenches” for that fort. William Houghton and Ben Titus could see clearly that Fort Washington was fully engaged by the enemy, and both felt certain that they would be sent across the river with other reinforcements. Ben later said that “about 200 of our men were in the ferry boat when word came that the Fort wastaken.” The men in Van Cleve’s and Houghton’s companies were fortunate that they hadn’t started across sooner and arrived at the fort before it fell. They soon learned that the entire surviving garrison of 2,828 men was captured. Ben, William and the other mencould only watch now as the fort, with all the entrenchments they had worked so hard to dig, was surrendered to the enemy. For now, the men of Heard’s Brigade at Fort Lee were separated from the British by the Hudson River, but they knew that it was only a matterof time before the British would cross the river and threaten them. They also knew that Fort Lee was much weaker than Fort Washington.

The next question was whether, really when, the British would cross the Hudson to attack Washington’s troops, and the Trentonians with General Heard, at Fort Lee. If they succeeded in also taking Fort Lee, where would they go next? The people ofTrenton were in the direct path of the British army if it headed for Philadelphia, as everyone suspected. General Charles Lee, still with his troops at Phillipsburg, New York, wrote to Dr. Benjamin Rush criticizing the army, commenting that the British may attempt to go toPhiladelphia, and, as he had previously suggested, called for a “Corps of Observation” to be stationed at Trenton, recognizing its strategicimportance in the line of communication.

‍

By Larry Kiddder
Related posts