The British are in New Jersey Nov 17-23,1776: Trenton 250

November 19, 2026
History

When news of the November 16 capture of Fort Washington first reached Trenton, merchant and Whig politician Samuel Tucker, living on today’s Warren Street near the battle monument, commented to Governor Livingston that he and others did not believe the story. However, the news would soon be confirmed.

Believing that Howe would soon send troops into New Jersey, on November 18 Governor Livingston directed Trenton’s Colonel Isaac Smith to detach some militiamen to go to Shrewsbury and prevent local Tories from communicating with the British fleet. Smith replied that the one-half of his regiment currently serving in the Flying Camp to defend New Jersey had not returned yet from their monthly tours. He also noted that they had been out six of the last nine months. The other half of his regiment was on their way to relieve them and, because weapons were being shared by the two divisions when necessary, he said “there are not arms enough now at home to arm” the needed troops. Smith apologized for presenting the facts so bluntly, but he just did not have the resources to carry out the orders as he understood them.

Events shortly got even worse on the night of November 19. About six thousand British troops led by General Cornwallis crossed the Hudson, landed unopposed about five miles above Fort Lee, and climbed the steep New Jersey Palisades. The following morning, they captured Fort Lee, along with most of the military supplies being removed from it by the Americans who had begun to retreat across the State with the British in pursuit. Militiaman John Anderson had turned out under Trenton hatmaker and militia Captain William Tucker to serve at Bound Brook and now joined the retreat toward Trenton along with the other militia and Continental troops in eastern New Jersey.

Washington raced to Fort Lee from Hackensack to direct the evacuation and retreat with General Greene. To save themselves, the men would have to retreat across the Hackensack River. They would have to use the New Bridge, the only bridge that could handle the large number of men involved, and if the British could capture it or the crossroads at Liberty Pole they could capture the entire retreating force.

With increasing urgency and undisciplined movements, the garrison began to leave the fort and head toward the Liberty Pole crossroads where Washington and his army awaited them. Most of the retreating troops from the abandoned fort were five-month levies, about two thousand poorly trained and not very effective troops, even though they had been with the Continental army for almost five months of on-the-job training that included several significant battles. They also only had about ten more days to serve on their enlistments that would end on December 1. During the clearly undisciplined fort evacuation, some soldiers broke into the sutlers’ liquor supply and eased their fears by getting drunk and were probably among the hundred or so prisoners taken when the British took the Fort. Nathanael Greene angrily described those prisoners as “a set of rascals that skulked out of the way for fear of fighting” and “had they obeyed orders, not a man would have been taken.” The British found a treasure trove at the fort consisting of large quantities of food and forage, abandoned artillery, entrenching tools, tents, ammunition, and over two thousand cattle. While the troops reacted as though they were being chased, Lord Cornwallis did not aggressively pursue the retreating Americans. Howe had ordered him to pressure the American troops, but not to bring them to a pitched battle. Both Cornwallis and Howe hoped they could bring the seemingly shattered rebellion to a close without instigating any additional costly battles.

Washington’s retreating forces headed west from Liberty Pole and crossed the Hackensack River on the New Bridge. After a long day on November 20 the Trenton men with Colonel Phillips’ regiment began an unsettled, cold and rainy night seeking places to sleep wherever they could. The men from the First Hunterdon undoubtedly dealt with emotions that had built up over the five months enduring the unsuccessful defense of New York. Their companies were undermanned because not enough of their fellow citizens had turned out as ordered and now the army was shrinking further as men around them deserted. They feared the British invasion of New Jersey would soon bring the war to their very neighborhoods, including Trenton, and put their families, homes, farms, and businesses in extreme danger. Although General Cornwallis ordered his troops not to plunder, the order was ineffective. The fears of the First Hunterdon men for the safety of their families were well founded.

When New Jersey militia General Matthias Williamson learned that the army was preparing to retreat, he ordered out the entire militia. However, this order resulted in “nothing but murmuring and desertion.” Williamson consulted with General Mercer and they agreed that, to keep at least some of the militia out, they would not let those militiamen go home whose monthly tour had expired. This move quieted things until the loss of Fort Washington, which immediately resulted in many desertions. Things had been even worse since the loss of Fort Lee, a loss that “seems to have sunk all their spirits & I am afraid by tomorrow morning [November 22] I shall have scarcely men sufficient to mount the common guards.”

Washington marched his army out on November 22, and the leading elements arrived in Newark late in the afternoon after a cold, muddy tramp. Newark was a market center for local farms, a little larger than Trenton, with about a hundred and forty houses spread out over about two miles. It was surrounded by excellent farmland that must have reminded the First Hunterdon men of their homes that they would soon be near. For now, though, the soldiers had to sleep on the wet, cold ground with whatever they could find to use for a blanket. Washington felt he must keep the army positioned between the British and Philadelphia, so he chose to move next to New Brunswick. At New Brunswick the Americans would be on the west side of the Raritan River and on the best road linking New York and Philadelphia – the road that would take them through Princeton, Maidenhead, and Trenton on the way to Philadelphia.

On November 23 Washington had about 5,410 troops in the Newark area, but over 2,000 of them would be leaving on December 1 when their enlistments expired. These included the Trenton men in Heard’s Brigade of the five-month levies.

Trentonians saw the publicly posted broadside written by Governor Livingston and addressed to the New Jersey militia colonels. It gave a summary of the actions from White Plains through the fall of Fort Washington. Livingston felt he needed to remind the militiamen of the cause they were fighting for and not just call them out on duty. He stated the reasons for the war emphasizing “British Injustice, and British Cruelty” that necessitated declaring independence. He repeated the call for everyone to fight for liberty for their descendants and not surrender without a struggle to “a ruffian Band of Mercenaries hired for our Destruction.” Livingston concluded by declaring to the colonels, “You are hereby directed to have the Battalion under your Command ready to march on the shortest Notice.”

With things rapidly falling apart militarily, men subject to militia service were still trying to figure out how to pursue their civilian jobs successfully while also fulfilling their military obligation. For many it was just not possible.

 By: Larry Kidder

‍

Related posts